วันอาทิตย์ที่ 23 ตุลาคม พ.ศ. 2559

Bangkok, a World Heritage City


Bangkok, a World Heritage City

Prof Dr Kriengsak Chareonwongsak
Senior Fellow, Harvard Univerisity’s Center for Business and Government

              According to Thailand’s Minister of Tourism and Sport, his proposal to develop the old cities of Chiengsan, Naan, and Lumpoon to be World Heritage sites is good policy. To me, it is also a very interesting idea. Currently, only five places in Thailand are registered as World Heritage Sites by the United Nations Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization, (UNESCO), which are, Ayutthaya’s historical garden, Sukhothai, Ban Chiang, Thungyai Naresuan – the Huai Kha Khaeng Wildlife Sanctuary, and Dong Phayayen – the Khao Yai Forest Complex. This is, however, far fewer in number than the many architectural, cultural, and national resource sites found altogether in Thailand.

              It can be noted from statistics of the World Tourism Organization that countries that are home to many World Heritage sites seem to be in the top ten tourist destinations (except for India). These countries welcome tourists from all over the world. For example, 41 World Heritage spots have been named in Italy, where the annual number of tourists is 37.1 million. Spain has 40 World Heritage locations, and the country welcomes 52.4 million tourists annually, and so on. For Thailand, (as Table 1 shows), five World Heritage sites have been named, and thus we welcome only 11.7 million tourists annually.

Table 1: Tourist statistics for ten countries having the most World Heritage sites 

Countries
World Heritage Sites
Tourists
Countries
World Heritage Sites
      Tourists
Ranking
No.
Ranking
Millions
Ranking
No.
Ranking
Millions
Italy
1
41
5
37.1
India
7
27
n.a.
3.5
Spain
2
40
2
52.4
Mexico
8
27
7
18.7
China
3
35
4
41.8
Russia
9
23
10
19.9
Germany
4
32
9
20.1
USA
10
20
3
46.1
France
5
31
1
75.1
Turkey
n.a.
n.a.
8
16.8
Great Britain
6
27
6
24.7
Thailand
n.a.
5
19
11.7
Note: Turkey is a country ranking eighth worldwide for tourist figures, though its number of World Heritage sites is not ranked within the top ten countries.

Source: UNESCO and the World Tourism Organization, (2005).

              Besides spots that the Minister of Tourism and Sport has tried to push for inclusion as World Heritage sites, there are many other temples and architectural sites that could be World Heritage locations, especially in the old city area, on Rattanakosin Island and in the surrounding area where there are many ancient historical places that would be worth naming as World Heritage areas. For example, such as Wat Benjamabopit, Wat Rachabophit, Wat Ratchanadaram, Wat Suthat, the Giant Swing, Golden Mountain, and other places.

              Thailand may earn more revenue from pushing these places as World Heritage sites. According to one academic analysis, statistics show that being named a World Heritage area could increase tourist income by about four times what it would usually earn. If this is true, then registering as a World Heritage would enhance Bangkok tourism to the tune of about 1.35 trillion a year; whereas currently it brings in an annual income of 336,621.89 million baht. Conversely, even if the tourist dollar does not rise, Bangkok’s enhanced World Heritage status would still bring other benefits to Thailand. Once any place is announced as a World Heritage site, not only does this indirectly advertise the site to  tourists the world over, but the country will also gain an educational fund and UNESCO support as a means of World Heritage site maintenance.

              However, should the government intend to push for Bangkok’s inclusion as a World Heritage location, we must not focus only on the total spending of tourists, but we must ensure that each tourist spends more money.  In addition, we must also be concerned for the fact that with an increase to the number of tourists, more problems will occur, for example, with increased city crowding, tourist attraction decadence, a lack of basic city infrastructure and facilities, with crime problems, and other problems.

              Thus, along with pushing Bangkok to be a World Heritage city, the government should also simultaneously develop businesses involved in World Heritage development. For example, businesses that sell souvenir products or that develop old city areas for high-end tourists with the provision of hotels and restaurants. Community culture should see a come back, as should old market life, and the re-creation of fun festivals or activities for tourists. We must also not forget to develop all transportation facilities, as well as providing tourist information, security services, tour guides, and whatever else may be needed for visitors.

              In addition, the government should create a campaign enabling people to cooperate in maintaining Thailand’s national pride where traditions are highly valued. We need to be serious about conserving Siamese architectural features, as well as improving Thai sightseeing as green and clean. We will need to cooperate with one another toward environmental maintenance in certain areas, including the restoration of old buildings and houses. We will probably need to place our city’s electrical wiring underground so as not to damage beautiful sightseeing effects. We will need to give a new splash of colour to city buildings, as well as changing city street signs, and modifying bus stop facilities, and public telephone boxes, with everything following the same theme to match the surrounding area.

              In my point of view, the authority concerned  must at this time push Bangkok to be a World Heritage centre. Besides earning far greater financial benefits through government policy tourism, this collective development of tourism will also serve to conserve the cultural and traditional heritage of Bangkok, to be with Thai people forever.



วันพฤหัสบดีที่ 20 ตุลาคม พ.ศ. 2559

The Hamburger Crisis and Asian Financial Cooperation



The Hamburger Crisis and Asian Financial Cooperation

Dr.Kriengsak Chareonwongsak
Senior Fellow, Harvard Univerisity

Two words best fit our global financial surge of recent times: “upside down.” In financial markets, the rich generally accumulate assets, and therefore play a role as creditors lending their financial resources to those who are poorer. Ironically, Asian, especially East Asian, countries have been the creditors of major Western countries, especially the USA, although the average per capita GDP of Asian countries is far less that of the Western hemisphere countries.
This phenomenon has occurred due to the vast current account deficit of the USA, as well as Asia’s enormous current account surplus. Without intervention of any kind, this international trade imbalance finally leads to US Dollar depreciation and Asian currency appreciation. Thus, to suppress currency market fluctuation, governments must manipulate their countries’ net capital inflow in order to compensate current account deficit/surplus. This mechanism operated when the American government issued a host of bonds that were largely bought by the Chinese government.
Unfortunately, to lure capital inflow, the US government ineluctably raised the Fed rate. It was a doubly-inauspicious situation for America when the rising US interest rate coincided with a bubble burst in the housing sector, causing a US credit crunch that has lasted since late 2007.
A tropical depression of credit crunch gusting to a hurricane of global economic crisis, is the reason why Asian financial sectors are now suffering. The credit crunch plus US and European financial market panic has aggravated their firms’ liquidity problem. Many parent companies in America and Europe have therefore drawn their money back from their subsidiaries in Asia. At Macro level, private capital outflow thus reverses back to America and Europe, causing tremendous plummets to the Asian stock market index and slight currency depreciation throughout Asia.
The tremendous private capital outflow implies that Asian firms are going to face a liquidity problem and there will be scarcity in borrowing resources. As a result, the private sectors of some emerging Asian countries, in Vietnam for example, will need financial resources to boost their liquidity.
Good news: Asia has abundant savings, relative to the rest of the world. That is, financial resources within Asia are available. Bad news: Asian intraregional financial integration is weak and nascent; the volume of private sector Asian intraregional capital flow is not large enough. Therefore, the cross-border borrowing and lending volume among Asian countries is too minimal to be significantly supportive in a mutual manner.
Many measures can be applied to indicate the level of financial integration, and almost all of them point to Asian financial integration as inter-regional (outside Asia) rather than intra-regional (within Asia). According to IMF statistics, Asia’s portfolio liabilities to other Asian countries are at least three times less than those to NAFTA or EU. This is also true in the case of portfolio assets. Osaka University professors have also found a convergence of savings-investment correlations among Asian countries, concluding that Asia’s regional financial integration has progressed since the 90’s, but is still left behind by other world blocs.
We know that Asian countries need financial resources to increase the liquidity of their private sectors, but their current financial integration level needs time to develop. That is, Asia’s current intraregional financial market is not functioning well enough to be of mutual assistance within Asia– not to mention financial resources from USA or Europe that because of the crisis are even more limited than in Asia. One single solution may lie in the area of G-to-G financial cooperation.
Many governments in Asian countries, especially Japan and China, have a cornucopia of public savings in reserve asset form. These untapped reserve assets can be utilized by lending them to governments in emerging Asian countries, which is now deemed to be less risky than lending them to crisis-affected Western countries, and more productive than just keeping them in treasure.
As for its indirect positive impact, G-to-G financial cooperation in Asia would not only support international trade, and political and cultural integration, but would also stimulate economic growth in emerging Asian economies which receive financial aid. Due to the crisis, within a very short time, exports to USA would be unable to function as Asia’s economic driving force, making intraregional trade possibly the best alternative. In the context of growing intraregional trade nowadays, an economic boom in neighbor countries is synonymous with an increase in import from trade partners. Ultimately, the positive effect is back to the lender.
I believe that the classic phrase, “give and take,” is still applicable in the case of Asian financial integration.